Skip to main content

Lost Art of D&D No. 2: Games Workshop's Holmes Basic (1977)



After Games Workshop attained the license to print a co-branded edition of TSR's 1977 Dungeons & Dragons basic rules book, they set about putting their own stamp on it, designing a new cover and replacing a number of the illustrations they deemed too crudely drawn for their U.K. market. 

The cover art was by John Blanche at the very start of his career as a fantasy illustrator. Blanche went on to be a mainstay at Games Workshop, producing countless illustrations for them. His fannish enthusiasm for the material--as an artist as well as a lifelong gamer--has deservedly made him a favorite over the decades.

I first encountered Blanche's work in the David Day compendium, A Tolkien Bestiary (1978), to which he contributed five illustrations that sit comfortably alongside the book's chief illustrator, Ian Miller. I have a special fondness for this book, having coveted it as a child during my incipient Middle Earth fixation. My parent's procured an out-of-print copy of the book for me for Christmas in 1979 by driving out of town to Cincinnati, Ohio where they actually had to bid for it in an auction. They sensed just how badly I wanted it, and this backstory was incredibly exotic to me at age nine. Just yesterday I ran my forefinger across the spine in my library remembering what a lucky and loved kid I was. 

As for the interior illustrations, a good number of them were replaced by Chris Baker's work, signed Fangorn (another Tolkien allusion). While he also contributed to Games Workshop products at various points in his career, he made a better living as a storyboard and conceptual artist for filmmakers such as Stanley Kubrick and Tim Burton. 

Interestingly, all of the art for which Fangorn drew substitutes was by either David C. Sutherland III or Tom Wham. David Trampier (aka Tramp) contributed three pieces to the "Holmes Basic" book that were wisely deemed strong enough not to be replaced by Games Workshop. Trampier's work throughout his time at TSR, despite its devotees like me, still seems to be underappreciated by fans of D&D-related art. The fact that his Wormy comic strip from the back of The Dragon magazine has never been collected in a reprint volume is one of the great oversights in TSR/Wizards of the Coast publishing history.

As you'll see below, most of Fangorn's illustrations are indeed an improvement over Sutherland's, but these substitutions don't come without some interesting shifts in tone. And not all are indisputable improvements (e.g., the lizard rider drawing accompanying Gygax's foreword). It's interesting to note how many of the Sutherland illustrations contain multiple protagonists, more akin to the adventuring parties common in Dungeons & Dragons game play, while Fangorn's illustrations never have more than a duo of heroes (see, for example, the illustrations on page 31 and 44). Sutherland's illustrations feel slightly more indicative of the spirit of actual game play even if Fangorn's are typically the stronger drawings. The loss of the Tom Wham illustration is unfortunate but understandable: Wham's goofy tone worked better in the context of The Dragon and other, larger D&D books in which it was a welcome grace note of humor rather than an odd anomaly, which is how it feels as the only illustration of its sort in this edition of D&D Basic.


Front cover: David C. Sutherland III (TSR, left) / John Blanche (GW, right)



Title page illustration: David C. Sutherland III (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)

Gygax's Foreword (p. 3): David C. Sutherland III (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)


Dwarf (p. 25): David C. Sutherland III (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)

Spot illustration (p. 26): Tom Wham (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)

Purple worm (p. 31): David C. Sutherland III (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)


Treasure (p. 33): David C. Sutherland III (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)


Magic Swords (p. 35): Tom Wham (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)


Magical Items (p. 37): David C. Sutherland III (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)


Spot illustration (p. 44): David C. Sutherland III (TSR, top) / Chris Baker, a.k.a. Fangorn (GW, bottom)


The Games Workshop edition of the Holmes Basic book replaces TSR's in-house price list that originally appeared on pp. 45-46 with a shorter version that lists its own gaming titles, fitting on just a single page (p. 46). In doing so, the GW edition also eliminates the below acknowledgment to Eric Holmes that appeared in the original TSR edition. The condensed price list and excising of the "About the Editor" note made room for an additional illustration unique to the GW edition.

 
This important bit of attribution from p. 45 was excised from the GW edition. 


This illustration appears on p. 45 of the GW edition, injecting a bit of an adult tone that was absent from editions of D&D Basic over the years but was more common in the Advanced D&D product line.


There has been some speculation that Chris Baker was originally tasked with drawing the cover illustration for the GW edition, a reasonable assumption given the fact that he was the only UK artist to appear in the interior. This piece below, which originally appeared in the Fiend Folio, has been pointed to as the piece that may have been originally commissioned as cover art for GW's Basic book.

Fiend Folio, p. 98 (Chris Baker, aka Fangorn)

Again, as others have noted, all of the elements are there that appear in the John Blanche piece that was actually used, even though one could also argue that the tropes presented--a dragon on a pile of treasure, a wizard, and a warrior--had all been standard fantasy fare for ages. Regardless, this image by Fangorn is arguably a stronger piece than either the Sutherland or Blanche covers. At least it eventually saw the light of day in the Fiend Folio some years later.

-----------

If these art excavations interest you, you may also enjoy the first installment in this series, Lost Art of D&D No. 1: Alex Nuckols.

And a special shout out to fellow Scrum Club member Zach Howard of Zenopus Archives, whose blog filled in some gaps in my knowledge.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Comments

  1. It's all about the art. That's what fired my imagination as a young kid reading these books.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That "oversight", sadly being at the will of the artist. Folks tracked him down years later and he was apparently bitter over his years in the gaming industry and uninterested in having his work reprinted. It'd definitely be a joyous thing if his estate might approve a collection of his work, or especially a general one and a Wormy collection.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Well-thumbed posts

Take the High Road: Making Cheap and Easy Dirt Roads

I have wanted some good roads to add to my games for a while now. My first attempt was a couple of years ago when my standards were a bit lower and I wasn't sure how much I was interested in investing in this new hobby. I bought some PDFs of cobblestone roads that I sized, printed, and glued to felt. The result was okay, but the way my laser printer  produced the roads ended up being quite reflective to the point of almost being glossy looking. The combination of glue, paper, and felt also meant the roads had a wavy consistency and almost always curled at the edges. I used them once or twice but was never happy with them. My sub-par first attempt at making roads for my games using felt strips, glue, and printed designs. You can see how shiny and how wavy and curled at the edges they turned out. I never felt good about putting them on the table for our games and eventually stopped altogether. I've been meaning to take another crack at making some roads now that I have

Chainmail: Battle for the Borderlands

It's always a pleasure to find new wargaming friends, especially when they fall in line with your own gaming ethos and level of dedication to crafting fun games. Eric Hoffman had been scheduled to be a game master at Scrum Con in both 2019 and 2020, but family illnesses torpedoed his intentions both times. It's no fun as a convention organizer to have to scramble to find a replacement GM at the last minute, but life often gets in the way regardless of best intentions, and I completely understood his situation.   But having never met Eric, it was hard to know if it was a big loss to our con and its players who had signed up for his games. Now that I've had the chance to play with Eric a couple of times, I can definitively confirm that it was indeed a big loss, and now I'm really looking forward to him being able to run a game for folks at a future Scrum Con. Eric finally did get to attend a Scrum Con event of a sort when we hosted our virtual Summer Invitational back i

Striking Back Against COVID-19: Free Conan Scenarios for 'Sellswords & Spellslingers'

Long-time readers of the blog will remember the adaptation of "Beyond the Black River" I started working on in the spring of 2018 for the  Sellswords & Spellslingers  rules. I ran it for the first time at Historicon 2018, and have now run it at several conventions and game days since. Sellswords & Spellslingers is designed for solo and co-op play, so to do my bit in helping the game community in its fight against boredom during these isolating pandemic days, I've decided to gather and organize all of the material I developed for my convention scenarios and make it freely available as a download via this blog. At the link further down is a 68-page PDF file with all of my player aids and notes. Of all of the major solo/co-op miniatures rules that have been released in the past few years, Sellswords & Spellslingers  is hands down the best if unfortunately not the most widely known or used. I highly encourage you to buy a copy of the rules, if you

All Together Now: 'Sellswords & Spellslingers' and the Pleasures of Cooperative Gaming

I've always enjoyed a good competitive match as much as the next guy, whether it was sports in high school or video games (HALO, etc.) in my thirties. But regardless of the game, I've always been partial to team play, and the best cooperative games put all of the focus on succeeding as a team. That's one of the reasons I was enthusiastic about getting Andrea Sfiligoi's latest release,  Sellswords & Spellslingers (Ganesha Games), on the table for this month's Second Saturday Scrum Club gathering. Last year I had organized a Halloween game ( recap ) to beta-test Sfiligoi's Run From the Dead , which is built atop the same cooperative mechanics as Sellswords . I was surprised when I discovered these rules were re-skinned for the fantasy genre and released last December ahead of Run From the Dead . Hopefully, the zombie apocalypse version of the rules is not too far behind because I definitely think  Run From the Dead  is the best tabletop miniatures rule s

An Arneson Clapback, or The Distortions of Axe-Grinding Revisionism

David Wesely, Gary Gygax, Dave Arneson (l-r) I posted the below on Facebook recently, and it is a sentiment I'm compelled to express all too frequently in discussions about the creators of Dungeons & Dragons on Facebook's gaming discussion groups in response to the gratuitous Gary Gygax bashing I see these days. "Dave Arneson gets way too much credit these days. David Wesely latched onto the role playing idea from germinal variations found in early kriegspiels, and Arneson repurposed Gary Gygax’s Chainmail rules to emulate Wesely’s idea in a different setting. Arneson was no game designer and could never hope to organize and codify a rule set for publication. You just have to look at what he produced in the field to see that (try reading and using that mess called First Fantasy Campaign ). While Gygax was churning out huge hardcover tomes that became the foundational bedrock for the game, Arneson was so useless at producing anything around the TSR offices that he eve